STATEMENT RESPONSE: CHANNEL 4 DISPATCHES
Statement following Channel 4 Dispatches “Rubbish Tip Britain” first broadcast on Friday 21st June 2024
Dauson Environmental Group is extremely disappointed with the tone, context, and content of the Channel 4 Dispatches “Rubbish Tip Britain” despite providing comprehensive information to the Production Company before broadcast.
Dauson Environmental Group employs over 250 people across Wales and contributes around £50m every year to the Welsh economy. The value at the core of our business is to clean up the environment, and as a business we are committed to recycling, redevelopment, and regeneration and are proud to provide a significant contribution to the total amount of waste recycling in Wales.
Waste management, by its very nature, is a highly regulated industry. Dauson Environmental Group is committed to maintaining these high standards of environmental management and transparency. We therefore regularly and openly engage with Natural Resources Wales and other appropriate stakeholders.
Withyhedge Landfill Site
Since the purchase of the site in 2022, Dauson Environmental Group has invested over £5m at the site in order to make significant improvements. We are unable to comment on activities relating to the site prior to our ownership. This includes alleged receipt of hazardous medical waste.
We are confident that the issue of odour has been resolved. In consultation with NRW, we have implemented measures to ensure that any odour from the site is minimised and does not affect the surrounding community.
We once again apologise for the impact this has had on local residents and our community.
However, whilst the broadcast stated that Public Health Wales has recently said that “hydrogen sulphide levels had exceeded safe levels”, in fact the levels recorded have only exceeded those associated with odour nuisance, not safety thresholds.
It should also be noted that Public Health Wales’ statement relates to a snapshot from approximately three months ago when samples were tested. Independent sampling and testing has been taking place for some time and we welcome updated sampling and testing to reassure the community.
Having reviewed footage of the alleged leachate leak captured by drone footage, we can advise that this shows a discharge into a containment ditch for surface water collection, and not into a waterway. This was not reported as such in the broadcast.
We understand that NRW is investigating water pollution in the area more generally which is likely to involve a number of local operators as well as other facilities further upstream. It is inappropriate to comment further until the investigation is concluded.
Waste Management
Withyhedge Landfill site does not knowingly accept non-conforming waste. This includes plasterboard, wood, tyres, and metal girders; Our waste acceptance procedures are stringent to prevent such materials from entering our site.
Our leachate is managed in strict accordance with our leachate management plan. We should make clear that the re-circulation of leachate is an accepted practice and not a violation of our permit. In addition, in excess of 35,000 tonnes of leachate has been removed from site in the past 12 months for treatment.
We are not aware of any ongoing inquiry into waste mis-categorisation or tax improprieties; however, we are committed to working with regulators to address any issues that may arise.
It should be noted that the claim in the programme that a typical artic load is between 30 and 40 tonnes is incorrect. The average load weight at our site is between 20 and 25 tonnes.
Drone footage
Dauson Environmental Group categorically denies the allegations of gunshots on our site. We would suggest that the investigators confused the noise with automated ‘bird scarers’ which are deployed on site
WITHYHEDGE LANDFILL SITE UPDATE : 31 MAY 2024
As confirmed in our statement on May 10th, the Withyhedge landfill site continues to be closed to all waste inputs, with the exception of engineering materials, to accommodate further engineering works.
Nearly £5 million has now been invested into the site over recent months and we will continue to invest as we take all necessary actions relating to previous issues on site. NRW continues to be updated, as the statutory regulator, and fully informed of our work and plans as we proceed.
For further information, in conjunction with this statement, RML has released a more detailed statement regarding the situation at the Withyhedge landfill site since Autumn 2023.
The continued work has resulted in the dissipation of landfill odour, and we anticipate this will continue to be the case going forward, notwithstanding the presence of other odour sources not related to Withyhedge Landfill Site in the vicinity.
In response to a statement from Pembrokeshire County Council (PCC) on May 29th 2024, RML wishes to confirm that the information requested by PCC has yet to be provided to them because the legal basis of their request is part of ongoing litigation and challenge in Court. As this legal process is ongoing, it would therefore be inappropriate to comment further at this time.
RML will continue to supply updates as necessary.
UPDATE: WITHYHEDGE LANDFILL PROGRESS
In the Autumn of 2023 RML anticipated the availability of void space becoming available in Cell 8 for continued waste disposal activities. Due to construction delays the void space was not available for disposal until late December 2023 and accordingly wastes were stored during the interim period on top of the cell that was active at the time (Cell 7). Wastes were deposited between October 2023 and January 2024 and were subsequently moved into Cell 8 in Jan and Feb 2024, allowing Cell 7 to be capped.
Odour complaints from the community around the site commenced in October 2023 and continued through the autumn. The odours were linked to the emission of landfill gas from the site containing hydrogen sulphide, a particularly smelly gas even at low concentrations. The production of landfill gas is ordinarily a relatively slow process, so it was thought likely that the odour originated in older deeper wastes; accordingly, NRW issued a Regulation 36 Notice requiring Cell 7 to be taken down to its final levels and capped in a short time period. The expectation at the time was that the deeper wastes would be contained by the cap and the gas collection system would draw off the gas and destroy it in the engines or flare.
After the removal of the stored wastes and the installation of a capping scheme and gas collection system on Cell 7 in early March 2024, the first indications emerged that Cell 8 was now producing hydrogen sulphide gas. This was unexpected, as the waste was all less than 6 months old and comprised conventional wastes that usually do not produce hydrogen sulphide gas in great concentration, or landfill gas in very short time periods. It appears that the wastes deposited originally within and on top of Cell 7 had a composition that resulted in the rapid production of landfill gas and hydrogen sulphide., The only option to contain the gas and mitigate the odour was to cap Cell 8 even though it was only partly filled.
NRW served a second Regulation36 Notice requiring capping works and gas collection systems to be installed on parts of Cell 8 but RML took the decision to cease waste inputs and to cap the entire cell. Over the coming months (and possibly longer) RML will monitor gas composition within Cells 7 and 8, along with other previous cells. Only when the gas composition reveals that it is safe to do so, will the temporary cap be incrementally peeled back to allow Cell 8 to be filled to its final levels before being permanently capped. It is expected that Cell 8 will be out of use for some time before conditions are right for the cell to be completed.
With Cell 8 out of use, Cell 9 is under construction. Cell 9, however, cannot accept wastes until those wastes that caused the rapid gassing along with hydrogen sulphide production are identified and prevented from entering the site. The chemistry of the incoming wastes has been examined to find substances that can combine to cause the problem, and a number of candidates have been identified. More may yet be identified. These wastes comprise only a small proportion of the wastes disposed of at the site but we are confident, having investigated matters, they are responsible for the issues seen. The bulk of the wastes appear to be free of contamination with the substances that give rise to hydrogen sulphide. Nevertheless, only when the company and the relevant statutory Regulators are content that the site can operate without a repeat of the previous issues will disposal activities commence in Cell 9.
Cell 9 will only accept wastes that have been screened and tested for constituents that produce hydrogen sulphide. Waste acceptance procedures will be agreed with NRW to ensure that robust exclusion methods are applied at the site. As well as carefully inspecting and testing incoming loads, Cell 9 will also be filled differently and monitored very closely to provide confidence that the waste mass is not generating and emitting unacceptable levels of landfill gas. The cell will be developed with inbuilt gas collection systems and pathways for gas to escape and will be designed out to ensure full containment. The facility to completely cover the wastes and activate effective gas extraction will be standing-by, on site, so that should the early signs be identified in the site monitoring, effective intervention can be immediate.
RML operated the site from March 2022 until autumn 2023 without complaints. It intends to operate the site for its remaining life on that basis and will continue to strive to do so.
WITHYHEDGE LANDFILL SITE UPDATE : 10 MAY 2024
RML has continued to update Natural Resources Wales (NRW) of progress at the Withyhedge Landfill site, remaining on track to complete all planned works by 14th May.
We publicly acknowledge and thank the dedication and hard work of our individual staff members who have worked to achieve these actions.
Once work is completed on 14th, the Withyhedge landfill site will be closed to all waste inputs, with the exception of engineering materials, from Wednesday 15th May pending the completion of further engineering works.
NRW has been fully informed of our plans and we will maintain communication with them as we proceed with these works.
RML will continue to supply updates as necessary.
WITHYHEDGE LANDFILL SITE UPDATE : 3 MAY 2024
As part of RML's commitment to provide an update on ongoing progress of works at Withyhedge Landfill site, we are pleased to report that the planned works are proceeding in alignment with the deadlines of the current notice issued by Natural Resources Wales (NRW).
RML continue to provide daily updates to NRW regarding all completed works. We are pleased to report that, following recent inspections by the regulator, NRW have released a statement declaring that RML has met the initial deadlines and “that three actions have been completed - two ahead of the imposed deadlines”.
To ensure local communities continue to be updated, we have updated our FAQ page to provide more information about the current situation at Withyhedge Landfill Site.
While we conclude works at site, we once again express our sincerest apologies to our neighbours and local communities for the impact this issue has had. We would like to provide reassurance that all efforts are underway to bring these works to a final conclusion.
We are pleased to report that recent observations indicate a notable reduction in landfill odours, both in occurrence and intensity. We anticipate this trend of a reduction on odour to continue as we near completion of ongoing works, notwithstanding the presence of other odour sources not related to Withyhedge Landfill Site in the vicinity.
In addition to this update, Pembrokeshire County Council released a statement on 2nd May 2024 which confirms a legal notice served against RML on Friday 26th April 2024.
Throughout this entire process we have worked hard to cooperate fully with Pembrokeshire County Council at all times. In doing so, we have ensured that they have been kept fully informed and up to date.
Whilst we are therefore disappointed with Pembrokeshire County Council’s decision, we will of course continue to engage fully with the council so that this matter can be brought to a conclusion for local communities.
As always, we will also continue to provide regular progress updates to all our stakeholders and communities.
WITHYHEDGE LANDFILL SITE UPDATE : 9 APRIL 2024
RML has been endeavouring to eliminate odours from Withyhedge Landfill site by carrying out engineering works required by a Regulation 36 Notice served on the company by NRW. The works required a large quantity of waste to be moved from the top of the landfill into the next Cell followed by capping the top and sides of the remaining wastes as well as the installation of gas wells and collection pipework. Despite the very poor weather during the engineering works, the excavation, removal, capping and well installation works are complete and last week the gas abstraction system became active.
Gasses from this part of the site are now being collected and over the next weeks the suction will finally collect the gases generated from this area. Recent surveys have confirmed the very limited escape of gases from this area.
Whist the company has had to focus on compliance with the legal Notice, it has also been mindful that the waste placed into the next cell has the capacity to generate gases. Gas collection scavenger pipes along with waste covering works have been undertaken by the company in this cell, but these are not yet fully complete. The company is aware that until these works are completed in the next cell, along with the provision of gas wells, there will still be the potential for odour to escape from the site. Now that the entire focus is on these works, RML is confident that they can be completed within a few weeks.
We share the community’s disappointment that the works on the capping area have not terminated the odour problems but can assure the community that the necessary works will be concluded soon, and the odour issue will be finally addressed.
WITHYHEDGE LANDFILL SITE UPDATE : 19 APRIL 2024
Following on from the completion of phase 1 of the remediation work to cap cells 6&7 and the installation and connection of the gas wells, and while we recognise odour issues in this area have abated, it is apparent that odour issues still persist.
We have completed further investigatory work to identify the source of the odour and have already commenced engineering work to address the issue; we share the frustrations of the local communities that these issues persist, and are extremely frustrated and disappointed that our work to this point has not remedied the situation as expected but would seek to assure everyone affected by the odours that we will not rest until we have a permanent solution.
We continue to work closely with the regulator, NRW and other specialist geotechnical engineers, and have submitted a plan of additional works to be completed; this work has been approved and has been included in a further regulatory Enforcement Notice with a deadline of 14th May 2024.
To this end, RML will post updates on progress weekly leading upto completion on the 14th May.
Any media enquiry, please contact: [email protected]